Skip to content

Practical guide · Marketplace / payment scams

Buying or selling online? Check payment requests before sending money

Has the buyer paid, and is the seller’s payment request legitimate?

By ScamPingPublished

Short answer

Check payment inside the real marketplace, bank or payment app. An email or screenshot is not sufficient payment evidence. Sellers should verify before shipping or refunding. Buyers should check which transaction and payment method the platform’s protection covers.

General guidance. Country and provider rules may differ.

If you already acted

How this scam usually works

Buyer route: an attractive listing starts the conversation. The seller then asks for a separate transfer or a payment outside the platform. You pay, but the promised item does not arrive or differs from the offer. This is a common pattern, not a finding about every direct sale.

Seller route: an interested buyer sends a supposed payment confirmation and asks you to ship, refund a duplicate payment or return an overpayment. The confirmation may be false, and a check may later be rejected.

Warning signs worth checking

Stronger indicators:

  • A supposed payment is missing from the official account records.
  • An unsolicited invoice charges for something you did not order.
  • A buyer sends an oversized check and directs you to pay the difference elsewhere.

Stop and resolve the discrepancy through the real provider.

Contextual signs: unusually low prices or reviews that lack useful detail. Compare the actual item, seller and terms; do not rely on star ratings alone. These clues justify checking, not a verdict.

What to check as a buyer

Read the listing, seller details and return terms, and retain the offer and messages. Check the marketplace’s protection rules for the specific item, payment route and claim deadline.

Under PayPal’s linked US guidance, payments marked Friends and Family are not eligible for its Purchase Protection. Goods and Services payments may qualify, subject to eligibility and limits. Check the rules for your PayPal account’s country; do not accept a seller’s claim that the two payment types provide the same coverage.

For example, eBay says transactions outside eBay are not covered by its Money Back Guarantee. That does not describe every marketplace’s rules or promise that every on-platform purchase qualifies. Use the platform’s current rules for your transaction.

If a stranger sends a PayPal invoice for something you never ordered, do not pay merely because it appears in PayPal. A real invoicing tool can carry an unwarranted request. Do not call an alarming phone number in the invoice note; use PayPal’s official account/support route.

What to check as a seller

Open the real payment account yourself. Check that a payment exists and follow the provider’s status instructions. Do not rely on a buyer’s screenshot, or refund a “duplicate” payment before the provider confirms it.

A request to buy gift cards or send crypto or a wire transfer from the proceeds of a stranger’s check is a fake-check pattern. Funds appearing in your balance do not prove the check is genuine. Ask your bank about the check; do not forward the money on the buyer’s instructions.

Before paying, shipping or refunding

Use the platform’s supported checkout when you want its stated transaction protections. If someone asks you to move outside eBay, pause: eBay prohibits that and excludes those purchases from its guarantee.

Do not share a login or verification code to prove you are a “real seller.” FTC describes buyers using verification-code requests to obtain codes rather than buy the item.

Report an unwarranted PayPal invoice or money request through the official account controls. Do not pay an unknown invoice to make the message go away.

If you already acted

Only replied to a listing or buyer
Pause the transaction and use platform support. Preserve the messages; do not send money or codes to resolve a claimed problem.
Entered a password or shared a sign-in code
Use the account provider’s recovery/security process, change the affected password and check for unauthorised access.
Shared payment details
Contact the issuer about protecting the account and checking charges.
Paid for an item or sent a refund
Contact the platform and payment provider promptly about available options. For mobile payments, use the app’s official reporting/support route. Recovery is not guaranteed.
Deposited a check and sent money back
Tell your bank immediately, explaining both the check and the outgoing payment. Do not forward more money.
Opened software or gave remote access to “fix payment”
End the access. Avoid sensitive logins on that device until it is checked. Use trusted technical help and updated security software; protect any accounts used during the session.

Common misconceptions

  • “HTTPS means this shop is genuine.” It protects the connection; it does not prove who is selling.
  • “An invoice inside a payment app proves I owe it.” PayPal warns about invoices for products/services never ordered.
  • “A protection logo guarantees a refund.” Check the platform’s actual eligibility and exclusions for that purchase.

Scope and limitations

This guide addresses payment verification in common online buying and selling scenarios. It does not assess a listing or guarantee a payment’s finality, an item’s quality or reimbursement. One red flag does not prove a scam; no red flags do not guarantee safety. A specific case needs separate review. Platforms, payment methods and countries have different protections and deadlines.

Check something suspicious

Answer a few questions to see what stands out and what to verify next.

Start Guided Check

No message, link or file needed.

Sources

References used to support this guide.

  1. FTC — marketplace buying

    Primary consumer guidance; platform coverage and buyer decisions

    Buyer checks, platform coverage and payment choices

  2. FTC — marketplace selling

    Primary consumer guidance; payment notices, refunds and codes

    False payment notices, duplicate refunds and code requests

  3. eBay — outside-platform transactions

    Official eBay policy; do not generalise to all marketplaces

    eBay-specific outside-platform and protection limits

  4. PayPal — invoice and money requests

    Official US guidance; real-platform and email invoice traps

    Real-platform invoices can be unwarranted; independent account route

  5. PayPal — reporting invoice requests

    Official US account/reporting procedures

    Official reporting controls

  6. FTC — fake-check mechanisms

    Primary consumer guidance; available balance is not authentication

    Overpayment mechanics, available balance and money forwarding

  7. PayPal — scam and protection guidance

    Official US guidance; support impersonation and eligible payments

    Scoped payment-type exclusions and eligibility

  8. FTC — online shopping checks

    Primary US consumer guidance; reviews, records, HTTPS

    Reviews, records, HTTPS and mobile-payment reporting

  9. FTC — mobile payment precautions

    Primary consumer guidance; recipient verification and reporting

    Reviews, records, HTTPS and mobile-payment reporting

  10. FTC — malware precautions

    Primary consumer guidance; device response, no scan guarantee

    Device access, payments and account response

  11. FTC — post-scam response

    Primary response guidance; payment/contact options, US identity resources

    Device access, payments and account response

  12. FTC — email/social account recovery

    Primary consumer guidance; provider-led recovery

    Device access, payments and account response